We Tried And Ranked 17 Of The Best Frozen Pizzas

Best frozen pizzas

pixabay

While frozen pizzas may not typically evoke thoughts of enjoying a freshly baked, mouthwatering slice, there are occasions when waiting for delivery is not an option, and frozen pizza becomes the go-to choice.

Testers

pixabay

A group of testers tried out every variety of frozen pizza available at leading supermarkets, assigning ratings ranging from 1 (barely resembling pizza) to 5 (almost like delivery). This way, you can avoid spending your money on lackluster options.

Totino’s Party

pixabay

17. Totino’s Party Pizza: Our expectations were raised when a taste-tester enthusiastically recalled enjoying this pizza almost daily as a child. However, upon tasting it, we quickly realized that this particular pizza was more suited for children or individuals with less discerning palates. Describing it as anything close to pizza would be an exaggeration—the cheese barely melted, the crust was unimpressive, and the pepperoni appeared oddly chunky, prompting one tester to declare that they wouldn’t even serve it to a dog.

Whole Foods

pixabay

16. Whole Foods 365 Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza: While Whole Foods excels in offering healthy food options, their pizza falls short of expectations. While none of the tasters disliked the pizza entirely, it only received an average rating. The primary criticism was that the pizza lacked flavor but had an excessive amount of grease, which was unexpected considering the reputation of the chain.

Amy’s

pixabay

15. Amy’s 4 Cheese Pizza: In a cheese pizza, the focus is on the cheese blend that tops the dough. However, as one of our testers noted, when there are fewer toppings, the cheese itself needs to be exceptional. Unfortunately, in this case, the cheese fell short of expectations and failed to impress.

Thin Crust Supreme

pixabay

14. Whole Foods 365 Thin Crust Supreme Pizza: Similar to the pepperoni pizza from Whole Foods, the supreme pizza also failed to impress. While one taster appreciated the freshness of the toppings, overall, the pizza lacked flavor. Another taster commented that it was not exceptional enough to mention to others. Nevertheless, it’s not a significant issue since Whole Foods is not typically known for being the top choice for pizza.

Tombstone

Youtube

13. Tombstone Original 5 Cheese Pizza: This cheese-only pizza, like many others, didn’t stand out. One taster described it as having tasty cheese but found the rest of the pizza to be mediocre.

Newman’s

Youtube

12. Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Uncured Pepperoni Pizza: One taster felt that this pizza was too thin to make a lasting impact. If you enjoy an extra crispy crust, this pizza may be appealing to you. However, due to the thinness of the dough, the sauce, cheese, and pepperoni may not be as substantial or flavorful as desired.

Amy’s BBQ

Youtube

11. Amy’s BBQ Pizza: While some tasters found the dough of this BBQ pizza to be a bit chewy, the standout feature was the sauce, which received high praise. The tangy sauce with a hint of spice elevated the pizza, making it a standout option that almost rivals delivery pizza.

Freschetta

pixabay

10. Freschetta Brick Oven Crust Roasted Mushroom and Spinach Pizza: One taster described this pizza as unexciting but not disappointing. The cheese is mild, the mushrooms have a roasted flavor, and the addition of spinach provides a refreshing touch of green. While it may not be exceptional, it is certainly enjoyable and would likely be a fantastic choice for a vegetarian pizza enthusiast.

DiGiorno

pixabay

9. DiGiorno Original Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza: The opinions among tasters were mixed when it came to this frozen pizza. Some enjoyed the pepperoni, while others thought it tasted too frozen. However, as time passed during the tasting, the pizza seemed to improve in the eyes of the tasters, ultimately leading to overall enjoyment.

Pepperoni Pizza

pixabay

8. Freschetta Naturally Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza: This pepperoni pizza was decent, but it didn’t stand out as anything extraordinary. The main issue noted by tasters was that the crust was a bit too thick, requiring a substantial bite. Despite this, it still delivered as a traditional pepperoni pizza.

Thin & Crispy

pixabay

7. Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Supreme Pizza: The vegetables and toppings on this frozen pizza are remarkably fresh, and there is a hint of spiciness for those seeking a little extra kick. Unfortunately, the cheese appears to be lacking, and the ultra-thin crust may result in a messy, crumbly pizza on your plate rather than a neatly held slice in your hand.

Supreme Pizza

pixabay

6. DiGiorno Original Rising Crust Supreme Pizza: The supreme pizza may have overreached with its toppings. While all the ingredients were fresh and tasty, they ended up overpowering the pizza. The sauce stood out as excellent, but the cheese seemed to get lost amidst the abundance of vegetables and meats.

Tony’s Pepperoni

pixabay

5. Tony’s Pepperoni Pizza: Despite initial doubts, one taster admitted, “I didn’t expect much from this, but I can’t seem to stop eating it.” Tony’s pizza may not be considered gourmet, but there is an undeniable appeal that keeps you reaching for more until every last bite is gone. Let’s just enjoy it without overthinking it.

California Pizza

pixabay

4. California Pizza Kitchen BBQ Chicken Pizza: CPK impressed with their BBQ-themed pizza. The chicken is moist, and the sauce strikes a perfect balance, resulting in a delightful experience. The only downside is the ultra-thin crust, which gives the impression of a flatbread rather than a traditional pizza. If you prefer a thicker, doughier crust, you might want to opt for a different choice.

White Pizza

pixabay

3. California Pizza Kitchen White Pizza: Described by one of our tasters as “light and subtly tangy,” this pizza perfectly fits that description. With a thin crust that leans towards a flatbread style, it offers a unique twist with a hint of Alfredo sauce flavor, elevating it above the standard white pizza and even surpassing the typical frozen pizza experience.

Red Baron

pixabay

2. Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni Pizza: One taster’s comment encapsulates the essence of this pizza: “It tastes better than it appears.” Despite its unimpressive appearance, the tangy and fresh sauce, thick crust, and flavorful pepperoni create a delicious combination that might trick you into thinking it was delivered from a pizzeria.

Double Down Deluxe

pixabay

1. Tombstone Roadhouse Loaded Double Down Deluxe Pizza: It’s clear that this pizza is a standout. With a harmonious blend of flavors, the toppings complement each other beautifully. The sauce is perfectly balanced, and the crust achieves just the right level of crispiness.