Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

U.S. News

Supreme Court Unanimously Sides Against Government in ‘No Fly List’ Case

via Pixabay

The Supreme Court unanimously ruled that a man’s lawsuit challenging his placement on the federal government’s “No Fly List” can proceed, finding that the government did not prove the case was moot after removing him from the list.

Yonas Fikre, a U.S. citizen, claimed the FBI unlawfully placed him on the list and pressured him to become an informant.

While the government argued Fikre’s removal meant the case was moot, the Court rejected this view, allowing the merits of the allegations to be examined in lower courts.

“Necessarily, our judgment is a provisional one,” Justice Neil Gorsuch stated.

“Just because the government has not yet demonstrated that Mr. Fikre’s case is moot does not mean it will never be able to do so,” he added. “This case comes to us in a preliminary posture, framed only by uncontested factual allegations and a terse declaration. As the case unfolds, the complaint’s allegations will be tested rather than taken as true, and different facts may emerge that may call for a different conclusion.”

Justice Gorsuch’s opinion acknowledged that further facts could still lead to a mootness conclusion later.

This initial ruling permits judicial scrutiny of the government’s national security policies while avoiding compelled disclosure of classified information, balancing security and due process considerations.

“A case does not automatically become moot when a defendant suspends its challenged conduct and then carries on litigating for some specified period,” Gorsuch said. “Nor can a defendant’s speculation about a plaintiff’s actions make up for a lack of assurance about its own. (For that matter, given what little we know at this stage in the proceedings, Mr. Fikre may have done none of the things the government presumes he has, perhaps wishing to but refraining for fear of finding himself relisted.)”

“In at least some instances, requiring the Government to disclose sensitive information regarding its grounds for placing or removing a person from the No-Fly List could undermine the Government’s significant interests in airline safety and the prevention of terrorist attack,” Justice Samuel Alito wrote.

Fikre’s attorneys welcomed the decision, which allows their client to seek further legal recourse after experiencing alleged harassment abroad linked to his placement on the list.

“We are proud to have helped Mr. Fikre secure justice through this unanimous US Supreme Court decision,” attorneys Lindsay Harrison and Annie Kastanek stated.

“Mr. Fikre was unconstitutionally placed on the No Fly List and stranded overseas for four years, and today’s victory underscores that the government cannot evade review of its national security policies by selectively mooting out cases,” they added.

Most Popular:

Hidden Camera Exposes Biden Official

Border Patrol Marksman Takes Matters Into His Own Hands

You May Also Like

Gallery

Charting the Course: Understanding Congressional and Legislative Maps. Federal judge’s ruling A federal judge upheld Georgia’s new GOP-drawn congressional and legislative maps, despite objections...

Politics

Prominent Atlantic City Democratic operative Craig Callaway has been charged with orchestrating a mail-in ballot scheme to sway elections. The U.S. Attorney’s Office in...

Gallery

The 2024 Presidential Showdown: Biden vs. Trump Redux Historic NBC Poll An NBC Poll has indicated that former President Donald Trump is leading President...

Gallery

Republican agenda dealt major blow by federal court. Overturned injunction The United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit overturned an injunction against...

Gallery

Understanding Food Contamination and Product Recalls in the US Multiple federal agencies Multiple federal agencies have issued a warning about potentially contaminated charcuterie meat...

Gallery

Karine Jean-Pierre continues to struggle during White House Press briefings. Weak answers Democrat lawmaker Jared Moskowitz of Florida condemned White House Press Secretary Karine...

Gallery

Nancy Mace: Trailblazer, Veteran, and Rising Political Star Significant staff turnover Republican Rep. Nancy Mace has experienced significant staff turnover, with her entire Capitol...